Policy Indications: UK Graduate route to open to international students on 1 July 2021  |  Leadership Instincts: VP appeals to students to connect their knowledge with social relevance  |  Leadership Instincts: Catherine Dulac receives Nomis Distinguished Scientist and Scholar Award  |  Leadership Instincts: Online school reviews reflect school demographics more than effectiveness  |  Leadership Instincts: Researchers virtually open and read sealed historic letters  |  Cover Story: At Vantage Point  |  Management lessons: Why Aluminium Cans are Great for Packaging of Beverages?  |  Parent Interventions: Motivation to Perform  |  Parent Interventions: Poor Quality Carbs Harmful for Heart  |  Parent Interventions: Beat Covid stress with Yoga  |  Education Information: Suggestions invited on Draft UGC Regulations, 2021  |  Life Inspirations: Little Acts of Kindness  |  Parent Interventions: Travel Local, Play Safe!  |  Art & Literature: IIT Hyderabad to hold techno-cultural fest Elan & nVision 2021  |  Teacher Insights: Minister releases Study Material of Indian Knowledge Tradition Courses  |  
January 22, 2021 Friday 12:55:52 PM IST

Randomized trials could help to return children safely to schools

Parent Interventions

Schools are closing again in response to surging levels of COVID-19 infection, but staging randomised trials when students eventually return could help to clarify uncertainties around when we should send children back to the classroom, according to a new study. Experts say that school reopening policies currently lack a rigorous evidence base - leading to the wide variation in policies around the world, but staging cluster randomized trials (CRT) would create a body of evidence to help policymakers take the right decisions.

The pandemic's rapid onslaught meant many public health policies had to be put into practice quickly despite uncertainty about the risks from SARS-CoV-2 and the effectiveness of various prevention measures.

An international research team says that when governments renew steps toward re-opening schools, there will be an opportunity to answer questions about the impact of closures on the transmission of the virus, as well as when and how these restrictions can be safely lifted.

Led by scientists at the University of Birmingham, the team - which includes experts from Harvard University, the University of Pennsylvania, and Western University, Canada - today published their findings in Clinical Trials.

Report co-author Professor Karla Hemming, from the University of Birmingham's Institute of Applied Health Research, commented: "As COVID-19 cases and deaths ebb and flow around the world, the question of when and how to withdraw public health policies is pressing.


Researchers noted wide variation between countries. Swedish schools remained open for under-16s throughout the pandemic, whilst Denmark, Germany, and Norway reopened schools after a period of closure. Italy and Spain chose to keep schools closed until autumn last year, whilst schools in Austria, the Czech Republic, and Russia have at times closed. Variability is also seen within the United States at state and county level.

Justifications for these decisions varied, with some officials relying on local test positivity rates and others focusing on numbers of new cases within schools.

Re-opening primary schools in Quebec, Canada, was associated with relatively few new cases, yet opening primary and secondary schools in Israel was associated with several outbreaks and the re-closure of some schools.

The researchers say CRTs are well suited to the rigorous evaluation of public health policies, with key aspects of trial design deserving special attention:

    1. Running such a study should only be considered when community transmission is under control and the health system has capacity.

    2. As the main interest is community transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the study would have to include many municipalities or regions.

    3. Entire regions (including all schools within) would be randomized to either remain closed or to re-open.

    4. For schools reopening, this would mean operating under precautions, including social distancing, mask-wearing, and possibly evening testing. Teachers and children who are clinically extremely vulnerable should be allowed to remain at home.

   5. For schools remaining closed, the burdens of keeping schools closed require careful consideration, especially for those who are more vulnerable at home.

Comments